Stuck in the Building: A Sketchbook Argument for Dignity in America's Waiting Rooms
Photo: Charles O'Rear, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
I keep a small sketchbook devoted to a category of American building that rarely appears in monographs: the place where you are stuck. The Greyhound station in a city I will not embarrass by naming. A county courthouse where the docket ran four hours late. The surgical waiting room where I spent a February night learning the acoustics of fluorescent fixtures. These are not the buildings we photograph. They are, I have come to believe, the buildings that matter most.
What the Lobby Photograph Hides
Every significant public project releases images of its atrium: the cantilevered stair, the terrazzo logo inlay, the reception desk in warm oak. These photographs are not false, exactly. They are simply taken in the first ninety seconds of a visitor's experience, when the building is still performing.
But most people spend most of their time in a public building waiting. Waiting is the true program. And waiting strips a building of its performance. What remains is the chair, the sightline to the clock, the question of where the restroom is and whether finding it requires asking a stranger for permission. A courthouse can have the finest stair in the state and still fail everyone who sits in its basement jury room for a day.
My sketches from these rooms share a vocabulary of small failures: clocks mounted where seated people cannot see them; power outlets absent, as though the waiting body is not expected to have a phone; windows set at standing eye level, so the view belongs to whoever happens to be up. None of these are code violations. All of them are design decisions—or more often, the residue of decisions made by people who never sat down.
The Ethics of Being Held
There is a difference between a building that holds you and one that merely contains you. The best waiting room I have ever sketched was in a small regional airport in the Mountain West: chairs arranged in short arcs rather than long rows, a window sill at seated height wide enough to rest a coffee and a paperback, and daylight arriving from two directions so that no one sat in another person's shadow. Nothing about it was expensive. Everything about it was deliberate. Someone had imagined being tired.
I would go further: the quality of a democracy's architecture can be read in its waiting rooms, because waiting is where citizenship is most evenly distributed. The wealthy and the poor wait in the same DMV. The courthouse corridor holds the lawyer and the defendant alike. When those spaces are generous, the state is telling its citizens something. When they are bleak, it is telling them something else.
Five Questions Before Drawing a Public Threshold
For colleagues designing civic buildings—and for the clients who commission them—I offer five questions that we now ask at Studio 8 before any public threshold is drawn:
- Where does a seated person look? Not a standing person in a rendering—a seated person, at seated eye level. What do they see: a wall, a door, the sky?
- Can time be read without standing up? Clocks, queue positions, and announcements must be legible from the chair.
- Is there a way to be alone in public? A bench by a window, an alcove, a corner with a view out. Anonymity with dignity is a form of comfort.
- Does the room work at 2 a.m.? Waiting does not keep business hours. What does this space offer the person here at the hardest hour?
- Would I wait here for someone I love? The final test, and the one that cannot be faked in a rendering.
A Modest Proposal
I am not arguing that lobbies be downgraded. Arrival matters; ceremony has its place. I am arguing that the photograph of the atrium should be preceded by a drawing of the waiting room, and that the second drawing should be the better one.
Architecture's public contract is signed in its humblest rooms. If we design those with the same attention we give the stair, we will have buildings that serve people not just at their best moments—the verdict, the departure, the homecoming—but in the long ordinary hours in between. Those hours are most of life. They deserve our best lines.